Dispute Resolution Clauses In Commercial Contracts

I don’t mean to argue against the undeniable wisdom of inserting a dispute resolution clause in a commercial contract at the drafting stage.

What’s not to like… it makes absolute sense to agree a dispute resolution framework before a dispute arises.

But there is a BUT.

Most clauses, and there are hundreds of versions, are drafted on the premise that the dispute should get to mediation sooner rather than later. Definitely before any arbitration/court proceedings are started.

Some are multi layered; 1) first negotiate, 2) move on to mediate, 3) then arbitrate or litigate as a last resort – often with a carve out for injunctive relief.

Many have strict time frames, often measured in days, so a party to a dispute can force the selection of a mediator and convene the mediation within a relatively short time of the dispute occurring.

Because of this, these types of clauses risk pushing parties through the doors of the mediation room too soon… before the dispute is mature, before the raw edges have been knocked off and certainly before the parties have adequate information about their own or the opposite party’s position and interests.

They come to the table without adequately defining to themselves, and each other, what the dispute is all about – upon what it is they can agree and disagree, without adequate document exchange and to be honest without adequately spending time wallowing in the conflict and all that it brings with it.

The realities of the dispute, some that only come with age – the stress, the cost, the creeping doubt – are missing.

Like a ripe cheese, these things take time.

Don't miss a story. Sign up for email updates.

We won't spam you and you can unsubscribe at any time. In signing-up, you agree to our privacy policy.